2011 Subaru Legacy

header-image
Rating8.3

Ranked #5 in 

Midsize Sedan
Write Review
$19,995 - $31,395
Starting Price 
Nathan Dyer's image
Nathan Dyer 

Senior Editor,

Updated on November 3, 2023

ProsConsWhat's New

Three versatile engines to choose from

Unimpressive Flat-6 compared to the Flat-4 variants

Added sunroof and satellite roof as standard

Offered in AWD improving the driving experience

Lackluster audio system used

2.5GT is provided as a limited trim from this model year

Spacious cabin for the segment

Top most trim available only as an automatic

Specs & Features

$24,995

price

256 hp @ 6000 rpm

horsepower

247 lb.-ft. @ 4400 rpm

torque

5-Speed Automatic w/od

transmission

3.6L 6cyl AWD 5A

engine

-

basic warranty

Overview

The 2011 Subaru Legacy sedan is a midsize sedan offered in 7 trims, starting off at a base MSRP of $19,995. For that price, it mainly competes with the Ford Fusion sedan, the Nissan Altima Sedan, and the Toyota Camry Sedan. Between 7 trims, the Subaru Legacy offers 3 powertrains. The first engine on offer is a 2.5L Flat 4 capable of making 170 horsepower and 170 lb-ft of torque mated to either a 6-speed manual or a Continous Variable Transmission (CVT). If more power is required, there is also a 256 horsepower-making 3.6L Flat 6 mated exclusively to a 5-speed automatic. Finally, for the top most trim there is a 265 horsepower making 2.5 turbocharged Flat-4 engine mated to a 6-speed manual. 

The Subaru Legacy reaches 60 mph from zero in 9.4 seconds on its base Flat-4 engine, which gets pumped up to 5.7 seconds with the Turbo version of the Flat-4. While the Flat-6 sits right in the middle with 7.1 seconds of 0 to 60. Depending on the powertrain, the Subaru Legacy can manage a combined fuel economy of between 20 and 26 mpg. While we’re on the topic of choices, the 8 striking colors the Subaru Legacy comes in really pull you towards itself.

Buying Advice

We recommend the 2.5i Premium trim which provides the best MPG numbers and features for a reasonable price. It comes standard with features such as power driver seats, leather-wrapped steering wheel, 16-inch alloy wheels, and so much more. Buyers can also opt-in for the optional Appearance package for $707.

Trims

    Base
    $19,995 onwards
    • 17-inch silver aluminum Wheels
    Premium
    $20,995 onwards
    • AM/FM stereo
    • Cloth Seat trim
    • Front manual air conditioning
    • Seek-Scan Radio
    R
    $24,995 onwards
    • Engine: 3.6L 6cyl AWD 5A
    • Horsepower: 256 hp @ 6000 rpm hp
    • Torque: 247 lb.-ft. @ 4400 rpm
    • 0-60 mph: 7.2 sec
    • Top Speed: TBD mph
    • Fuel Economy Combined: 20 mpg
    Limited
    $25,295 onwards
    • Dual zone automatic front air conditioning
    • Leather Seat trim
    H6 3.6R Ltd Pwr Moon/Navigation
    $28,295 onwards
    • Engine: 3.6L 6cyl AWD 5A
    • Horsepower: 256 hp @ 6000 rpm hp
    • Torque: 247 lb.-ft. @ 4400 rpm
    • 0-60 mph: 6.7 sec
    • Top Speed: TBD mph
    • Fuel Economy Combined: 20 mpg
    GT Limited
    $31,395 onwards
    • 18-inch silver aluminum Wheels
    • Front Fog/driving lights
    • Sliding and tilting glass Sunroof

Compare to similar cars

Price

$19,995- $31,395

Engine

Gasoline

Rating

8.28

Horsepower

265 hp @ 5600 rpm

Torque

258 lb.-ft. @ 2000 rpm

Capacity

7

Read Review

$27,130- $33,900

Gasoline

8.01

182 hp @ 6700 rpm

172 lb.-ft. @ 4900 rpm

5

Read Review

$21,975- $27,165

Gasoline

8.1

169 hp @ 6400 rpm

160 lb.-ft. @ 4500 rpm

5

Read Review

$19,245- $31,940

Gasoline

8.52

173 hp @ 6000 rpm

166 lb.-ft. @ 4400 rpm

5

Read Review

$19,245- $23,745

Gasoline

7.54

173 hp @ 6000 rpm

166 lb.-ft. @ 4400 rpm

5

Read Review

$19,850- $29,000

Gasoline

8.22

175 hp @ 6000 rpm

172 lb.-ft. @ 4500 rpm

5

Read Review

$21,380- $31,930

Gasoline

8.06

177 hp @ 6500 rpm

161 lb.-ft. @ 4300 rpm

5

Read Review

$19,395- $27,245

Gasoline

8.25

198 hp @ 6300 rpm

184 lb.-ft. @ 4250 rpm

5

Read Review

$22,250- $43,000

Gasoline

7.64

290 hp @ 6200 rpm

264 lb.-ft. @ 4500 rpm

5

Read Review

$25,495- $30,095

Gasoline

7.37

260 hp @ 6200 rpm

233 lb.-ft. @ 4500 rpm

5

Read Review

2011 Subaru Legacy vs competitor's 0-60

    Car Name
    0-60 MPH
    Quarter Mile
    Top Speed
    SourceCompare
    8.4 sec16.6 sec-
    5.9 sec--
    6.4 sec14.8 sec-
    6.7 sec--
    6.8 sec15.3 sec-
    7.1 sec--

    2011 Subaru Legacy vs competitor's MPG

      Car Name
      MPG City
      MPG Highway
      MPG Combined
      Fuel Tank Capacity
      Range (C/H)
      SourceCompare
      23 mpg27 mpg22 mpg18.5 gal.351.5/499.5 mi.
      24 mpg35 mpg28 mpg18.5 gal.444/647.5 mi.
      22 mpg35 mpg28 mpg18.5 gal.444/647.5 mi.
      23 mpg34 mpg27 mpg18.5 gal.425.5/629 mi.
      23 mpg32 mpg27 mpg20 gal.460/640 mi.
      22 mpg33 mpg26 mpg18.5 gal.407/610.5 mi.

      2011 Subaru Legacy vs competitor's dimensions

        Car Name
        Length
        Width
        Height
        Ground Clearance
        Wheelbase
        SourceCompare
        186.4 in.71.7 in.59.3 in.5.9 in.108.3 in.
        206.6 in.72.8 in.68.7 in.5.7 in.125.9 in.
        2011 Saab 9-5

        Ranked #2

        197.2 in.83.2 in.57.8 in.6 in.111.7 in.
        196.9 in.73.1 in.59.2 in.7 in.111.7 in.
        195.9 in.74.4 in.58.1 in.5.2 in.115.6 in.
        194.1 in.72.7 in.58.1 in.6 in.110.2 in.

        2011 Subaru Legacy vs competitor's trunk space

          Car Name
          Trunk Capacity
          Passenger Volume
          Max Trunk Volume
          SourceCompare
          14.7 cu.ft.103 cu.ft.38 cu.ft.
          27.1 cu.ft.105.4 cu.ft.113 cu.ft.
          13.5 cu.ft.100.5 cu.ft.50.3 cu.ft.
          16.5 cu.ft.100.3 cu.ft.17.7 cu.ft.
          2011 Mazda 6

          Ranked #3

          16.6 cu.ft.101.9 cu.ft.73 cu.ft.
          14.2 cu.ft.95.8 cu.ft.64.5 cu.ft.

          2011 Subaru Legacy vs competitor's cargo space

            Car Name
            Cargo Volume
            Cargo Volume w/ Seat Area
            Max Cargo Volume
            Bed Length
            SourceCompare
            38 cu.ft.14.7 cu.ft.38 cu.ft.-
            83.1 cu.ft.16.5 cu.ft.17.7 cu.ft.-
            14.5 cu.ft.15 cu.ft.14.5 cu.ft.-
            62.51 cu.ft.16.6 cu.ft.62.51 cu.ft.-
            9.7 cu.ft.14.7 cu.ft.9.7 cu.ft.-
            15.1 cu.ft.13.3 cu.ft.13.1 cu.ft.-

            2011 Subaru Legacy vs competitor's towing capacity

              Car Name
              Towing Capacity
              Payload Capacity
              Weight
              SourceCompare
              -1165 lbs.3270 lbs.
              2011 Saab 9-5

              Ranked #1

              3748 lbs.3968 lbs.-
              2000 lbs.1144 lbs.3576 lbs.
              1000 lbs.1206 lbs.3243 lbs.
              1000 lbs.1211 lbs.3389 lbs.
              1000 lbs.925 lbs.3263 lbs.

              2011 Subaru Legacy Sedan Problems, Issues, Complaints, Recalls, and which year to avoid?

              16

              Recalls

              0

              Investigations

              163

              Complaints
              Overall Safety Rating
              Read More

              Top Subaru Cars

              2011 Subaru Tribeca

              Horsepower : 256 hp @ 6000 rpm

              MPG Combined : 18 mpg

              0-60 : 6.6 sec

              #1

              2011 Subaru Impreza

              Horsepower : 170 hp @ 6000 rpm

              MPG Combined : 22 mpg

              0-60 : 8.2 sec

              #2

              2011 Subaru Forester

              Horsepower : 170 hp @ 5800 rpm

              MPG Combined : 23 mpg

              0-60 : 8.8 sec

              #3

              2011 Subaru Legacy

              Horsepower : 170 hp @ 5600 rpm

              MPG Combined : 22 mpg

              0-60 : 8.4 sec

              #4

              2011 Subaru Outback

              Horsepower : 170 hp @ 5600 rpm

              MPG Combined : 22 mpg

              0-60 : 8.7 sec

              #5