2019 Subaru Forester Problems And Complaints

header-image
Rating7.1

Ranked #6 in 

Compact SUV
Write Review
$24,295 - $34,295
Starting Price 

Users Opinions on 2019 Subaru Forester

Recommended mentioned in Reviews

Write a Review

Disliked by Users

  • TM

    TERESA MACINNES

    26/09/2023

    Rating:

    (1 Out Of 5 stars)

    I dislakie spending $1500.00 for a replacement part that is only 4 years old - this has been an ongoing problem with this make and model - why not a recall??

    Source: edmunds

  • D

    Dan

    05/01/2023

    Rating:

    (2 Out Of 5 stars)

    Maybe my 2019 was a lemon but I’ve heard of lots of complaints about the lift gate for sure. Kinda sucks coming out of the grocery store and can’t get the lift gate to open. Next problem has been the main computerRead More

    Source: edmunds

  • PT

    P. Thank

    08/02/2021

    Rating:

    (1 Out Of 5 stars)

    ... want to own a car that I can't drive at night. This is my last Subaru. Update: I am still scared to drive at night. Since my review, I voiced my concerns on Car Guru to see if others were experiencing the same problem. There have been several responses from owners of other car makes (Toyota, Honda) who have experiences the same concern.Read More

    Source: edmunds

2019 Subaru Forester Crossover Problems, Issues, Complaints, Recalls, and Which Year to Avoid

3

Recalls

0

Investigations

812

Complaints
Overall Safety Rating
Nathan Dyer's image
Nathan Dyer 

Senior Editor,

Updated on August 6, 2024

SUVs are mostly bought by the crowd that is looking for a family vehicle to keep the drive as relaxed and easy as possible. The Subaru Forester is one such SUV that falls in the sub $25,000 price tag and yet provides great value as it’s known to balance performance and reliability very well. The same is the case for the 2019 Subaru Forester and the tiny 3 recalls only prove the car to be reliable. However, there have been 565 total registered complaints from the owners and that does let the completion like the Nissan Rogue, the Volkswagen Tiguan, and the Chevrolet Equinox have a better reputation in the market. Let’s analyze those complaints and see if they are red flags.

User complaints and problems

Electrical Problems

  • Tailgate – The tailgate button on the dashboard or the key fob failed to open the door and needed the battery to be disconnected for a while before reconnecting to get it working
  • Instrument cluster – The entire lights on the dashboard and the cluster stopped working and this also killed the headlights and the turn signals. The mechanics weren’t able to find the issue with the car.
  • Starlink – It was found that the Apple Car Play, radio, and navigation system becomes inoperable after starting the car using the mobile Starlink feature
  • Infotainment – The touchscreen was said to be unresponsive at times making it a hassle to operate when driving.

Mechanical Problems

  • Engine – The Forester has been reported to stall after trying to accelerate at traffic signals. It was also reported by multiple owners that during a crash, the engine area easily catches fire leading to the entire car burning down to crisp.
  • Brakes - The forward collision avoidance system was seen to engage with sudden braking even though there weren’t any vehicles ahead. This car easily causes an accident if there are other vehicles behind.
  • Fuel system – It was noted that the fuel system wasn’t functioning right which led to multiple jerks when accelerating the car. Sudden unexpected acceleration can increase the chance of a crash.
  • Steering – The steering wheel was reported to lock up while the car was cruising at 60MPH. The driver had to pull over and restart the car to fix this issue.
  • Suspension – The owner was driving on an interstate with a windy climate condition when he noticed the car swaying aggressively which is unsafe and increases the chance of a crash.

Safety Problems

  • Lane keep assist – This safety feature was reported to read wrong makings on the road which automatically tried switching the lane with other cars in it before the driver could forcibly counter steer to avoid a crash.
  • Airbags – The airbag sensor was reported to not register and activate when kids weighing 100 pounds were seated even after buckling up the seatbelt. There also were instances where the airbags failed to deploy during a crash.

Exterior Problems

  • Windshield – Owners started to notice a crack in the windshield and some even claimed that the crack got larger over time.

Interior Problems

  • Instrument cluster – The tire pressure monitor system does give out the information on the Starlink mobile app but does not display it on the instrument cluster.

Recalls

S. No.

Date

NHTSA ID

Issues Noticed

Additional Remarks

Remedy

1

15th April 2021

21V263000

Rear stabilizer bracket bolts may detach

The rear stabilizer bolts may loosen and detach which increases the risk of a crash.

The dealers will retorque and replace any mission bolts.

2

2nd December 2019

19V856000

PCV valve can separate

Separation of the Positive Crankcase Ventilation valve can allow the separated components to enter the engine, resulting in a loss of power.

PCV valve will be replaced. If it has already been separated and the components cannot be found, the short block engine will be replaced.

3

6th February 2019

19V065000

Loss of electric power steering assist.

The connector inside the electronic power steering unit may short circuit and cut the electric steering assistance completely. This would require the driver to use extra force to maneuver the car.

Subaru notified the dealers about this issue even before the cars were sold to the customers. The steering assembly will be inspected and replaced if necessary.

Should you buy the 2019 Subaru Forester?

With no major complaints or issues and a very limited recall from Subaru, the Forester is a car that would spend a slim time with the mechanics. The compact SUV segment has numerous players but the Subaru Forester will be a great purchase and we highly recommend checking this car out if you haven’t thought about it. This car has enough power and space that is required for an average family and the fact that the Forester comes with an all-wheel-drive as a standard feature makes it feel very stable and safe on the road. The Subaru Forester also has one of the best off-road ability and ground clearance in its segment.

  • Complaints
  • Recalls
  • Investigations
  • Manufacturer Communications

September 24, 2025, NHTSA ID Number: 11689473

Components: 100000 POWER TRAIN

NHTSA ID Number:
11689473

Incident Date:
September 24, 2025

Vehicle Identification Number:
JF2SKAGC1KH

Consumer Location:
SANTA CLARA, CA

Summary
50k Mileage Mark: When the vehicle turned off at the stop light to save gas, the car stalled. I had to fr...

September 24, 2025, NHTSA ID Number: 11689526

Components: 110000 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

NHTSA ID Number:
11689526

Incident Date:
September 24, 2025

Vehicle Identification Number:
JF2SKACC8KH

Consumer Location:
EAGLE, ID

Summary
Car has died 10+ times in the last 2 weeks. Will not hold a charge and it's getting to the point that my ...

September 9, 2025, NHTSA ID Number: 11686000

Components: 060000 ENGINE (PWS)

NHTSA ID Number:
11686000

Incident Date:
September 9, 2025

Vehicle Identification Number:
JF2SKAUC0KH

Consumer Location:
MONTGOMERY VILLAGE, MD

Summary
At a stop light, auto stop engaged. When foot put on gas, engine died and every warning light the car ha...

September 4, 2025, NHTSA ID Number: 11685026

Components: 110000 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

NHTSA ID Number:
11685026

Incident Date:
September 4, 2025

Vehicle Identification Number:
JF2SKAWC4KH

Consumer Location:
PERRY, OH

Summary
My 2019 forester touring. The sound system will randomly raise to extremely high volume. It's an extremel...

August 20, 2025, NHTSA ID Number: 11681834

Components: 980000 UNKNOWN OR OTHER

NHTSA ID Number:
11681834

Incident Date:
August 20, 2025

Vehicle Identification Number:
JF2SKAWC4KH

Consumer Location:
CARRBORO, NC

Summary
My Subaru smelled like gas and caught on fire while I was driving to work less than 72 hours after it lef...

72/100Best

Quality & Reliability

Assesses the extent of issues, glitches, and design imperfections encountered by...

81/100Best

Driving Experience

Owners' assessments regarding the vehicle's design, performance, comfort, functi...

82/100Best

Resale

CARHP's projection of depreciation, which estimates the probable decrease in the...

84/100Best

Dealership Experience

Owners' interactions with dealerships associated with this brand, encompassing b...

Similar Cars

2019 Subaru Forester
2019 Subaru Forester

MSRP: $24,295- $35,270

7.1/10
2019 Subaru Crosstrek
2019 Subaru Crosstrek

MSRP: $21,895- $28,170

6.2/10
2019 Honda CR-V
2019 Honda CR-V

MSRP: $24,450- $34,250

7.2/10
2019 Hyundai Santa Fe
2019 Hyundai Santa Fe

MSRP: $25,750- $38,800

6.9/10
2019 Jeep Compass
2019 Jeep Compass

MSRP: $21,845- $31,690

6.3/10
2019 Buick Envision
2019 Buick Envision

MSRP: $31,995- $43,600

6.0/10
2019 Chevrolet Equinox
2019 Chevrolet Equinox

MSRP: $23,800- $35,700

6.1/10
2019 Ford Escape
2019 Ford Escape

MSRP: $24,105- $34,120

6.1/10
2019 GMC Terrain
2019 GMC Terrain

MSRP: $25,000- $39,500

6.3/10
2019 Honda HR-V
2019 Honda HR-V

MSRP: $20,620- $28,640

6.1/10